Too many near-identical choices. Three similar Chardonnays do not create variety; they create hesitation.
Technical descriptions. Soil, clone, and élevage can support the story, but they should not be the front door.
A missing middle. A sharp jump from entry-level to luxury can strand guests who want to trade up modestly.
The forgotten wildcard. Without one discovery pour, the list may work—but it will rarely surprise anyone.
No staff ownership. The best-designed list fails when the team has not tasted it, practiced it, and found language that feels natural.